You may have read my previous post that I'm trying to use data to work out why I'm sometimes not sleeping well and how I might sleep better. I've been doing that now for some 86 days and I'm excited enough to look at the data and see if anything interesting has shown up. Ideally I'd like a year's worth of data to get reliable results, but I'm impatient.
You may be wondering why the title of today's post is so undramatic, prosaic even. Well, I'm rather a newbie when it comes to statistics and I don't want to leap to conclusions from the first thing I try. As you'll see from my GitHub project, all I've done so far is to read in the data and use Python Pandas to produce the correlation results. I then pasted this into a spreadsheet, sorted and highlighted some rows.
I'm also wary that correlation does not imply causation. But it does make for an interesting start.
With those caveats out of the way, this is what I've got so far.
The factor I'm hoping to maximise is "Hours that night" - how many hours I sleep on a night after all those potential influences have been measured. So I'm interested in things which might be positive or negative influences on that.
The top two I've put in grey, as I think they're not very interesting, except to show that the correlation function seems to be working as expected. - "Max possible" is low when I have to get up very early, say to travel somewhere, so it's always going to limit my sleep. - "Av hrs past 5 days" is a rolling average of "Hours that night" over the last 5 days. That I'm more likely to sleep if I've built up a huge sleep debt recently is unsurprising, but also confirms that the model seems reliable. - ZMA and FOS are two supplements I've been taking recently which are said to help with sleep, the ZMA particularly for those doing a lot of exercise. Evidence is limited and I'm not keen on trying every eccentric treatment "because you never know", but they're cheap and the side-effects are trivial. However, I've only been taking these for a couple of weeks, so I don't think there's enough data to say if they have helped me.
If I had guessed I would've expected "Evening meal finish" - the time at which I finish dinner to have had the greatest negative effect on my sleep as I often wake early feeling boated if I've eaten late. It does seem to be a negative factor, along with "Evening meal size (0-5)". I'll aim to eat earlier and keep recording results.
This wasn't a significant factor for me. This is supposed to make you fall asleep later but wake up too early, losing sleep overall. Anecdotally, I have found to be true for me. However, I drink quite rarely and haven't had more than four units a day in any of the last 86 days, so my stats so far may not say much about that.
I'm recording these as they've either been blamed for bad sleep or hailed as a helpful thing. They don't seem to be a big deal for me. I may consider stopping recording them so I have more time/space for other data.
It interesting that these have some negative effect on my sleep, but as they're all-day values, there's probably not a huge amount I can do to control them.
I am surprised and, if I'm honest, disappointed to see "Exercise (1-5)" as such an apparently bad influence on my sleep. Studies have suggested that exercise should have a positive effect on sleep, but that may depend on intensity. For me, and exercise score of 1 indicates a day where I didn't walk for more than 15 mins and did no other exercise, 2 a normal day where I cycle to/from the station, about ten minutes each way, 3 is a bike ride of up to 3 hours or a 20-min weights/callisthenics session, 4 is a 3-6 hour bike ride, 5 is reserved for the all-day and sometimes all-night rides I occasionally do.
Perhaps this isn't enough data on what, for me, may be an important question. Questions I'd like to answer might include. - Is morning exercise better or worse for sleep than evening exercise? - Is moderate exercise better for sleep than either extreme? - Does taking ZMA (or something else) mitigate the apparently negative effects of exercise on sleep?
Finally, instead of simply "Hours that night" should I be measuring the sleep I got as a fraction of the "Max possible" sleep? That might account for strange circumstances where I was still cycling at 1am and inevitably scored a 5 for "Exercise".
I shouldn't be drawing any firm conclusions yet, I think. 86 days is not that much data and there are many confounding factors that could be influencing things. I have a lot of thinking, learning and tweaking to do. I plan to keep recording the data, expand my exercise data to include AM/PM and separate short intense efforts from longer endurance ones.
I'm hoping to maximise "Hours that night" - how many hours I sleep on a night after all those potential influences have been measured.
Is morning exercise better or worse for sleep than evening exercise?